- Horace Webster, 1847-1869
- General Alexander S. Webb, 1869-1902
- John H. Finley, 1903-1913
- Sidney Edward Mezes, 1914-1927
- Frederick Robinson, 1927-1938
- Harry N. Wright, 1941-1952
- Buell G. Gallagher, 1953-1970
- Robert Marshak, 1970-1979
- Bernard W. Harleston, 1981-1992
- Yolanda T. Moses, 1993-1999
- Gregory H. Williams, 2001-
